Friday, March 25, 2016

Lying = OK

Exactly seven years ago 0.I was la0id-off from my job at one of the big four consulting companies. A lot of interesting things happened since then. One of the most surprising events though happened earlier this week when my former boss who actually fired me seven years ago, reached out and asked to write a five-star review on Amazon for his book that he published last year.

I have to admit that I actually never hated the guy and even was glad when I was let go because I was trying unsuccessfully to leave that company for at least six months prior to that day. So I got three months worth of pay and a huge incentive to find a better job. And I did find a better job! The money went toward buying a new iMac (that I still use today) and a trip abroad.

We never really were friends but once X (let's call him X) launched his writing career about two years ago he became more active on social media and we became friends on Facebook. Part of me was really curious about knowing a writer and seeing what writers are made of so to speak, another part of me actually liked the guy - he was always straightforward, reasonable, one of the better bosses that I had in my career.

So needless to say that I bought his book the moment it came out. And oh boy was it bad... I tend to write a review on Goodreads once I finish a book but this time I just quietly marked it as "read" and hoped that X wouldn't notice.

Fast forward one year, and here I am with this dilemma - can I write a five-star review about a book that I absolutely hated?

My answer was: "Yes."


And I know that a lot of people wouldn't do it but also know a lot of people would do it (and did) without blinking.

I believe in helping your friends and people you know and generally like. Especially when they need help. I buy my friends' music albums, paintings, go to their concerts, take their pictures. I think it's important to help each other. So I think this case is very similar. But with one exception - I had to lie.

I don't like lying.

And I happen to believe in stretching the boundaries of acceptable when it comes to not telling the whole truth. Sometimes when you are helping others you are doing something you don't particularly like. And I was able to find an angle that let me write a more or less truthful review where the actual rating was the biggest lie.

So the bottom line is that I tried staying true to myself - I wrote what I really thought about the book, focusing on the positives or even perceived positives (like it being fast paced and packed with action).

On a plus side I also got something out of this - I got to ask X a couple of questions about his writing career that gave me some useful insight into the world of writing. As I am also an aspiring writer, I need all the advice and help I can get so this was really a great opportunity!

In the end his answers inspired me to write more and fight on so I think that was a lie well spent ;)

Of course some people would be shocked by the fact that X asked me to write a FIVE-STAR review! What a nerve! But I really liked that he was honest. What's the point of beating about the bush if you really want a five-star review? I could have said no if I didn't want to do it. And then he was even honest about his writing skills, saying that he wasn't sure the book was worth reading. So I traded my life for his honesty.

So what is the moral of this story? I guess that not everything is what it seems at the first glance and even lying isn't that straightforward as it is usually thought of. And most importantly, if you have to lie, you have to feel it and believe it yourself. Do not slip up!

Friday, March 18, 2016

Trashing Nabokov

A middle-aged man that absolutely loves girls between 9 and 14 years old marries a woman to get closer to her 12 year-old daughter. But his wife still stands between him and her daughter so he plans to kill her. And suddenly she dies. So the man takes the girl away from their home town and starts traveling across America forcing the girl to have sex with him. He frightens her with consequences of being left with no one to support her and even pays for the sex.



Now imagine that you learn all this from the man himself. Well, you really don't have to imagine it, you can read this whole story in Vladimir Nabokov's novel Lolita. 

I am not sure if I was more put off by the pedophile rapist's confessions or by the fact that he is so full of himself. His tone is highly irritating - pretentious and snobbish.

It's hard for me to identify myself with the main protagonist and I don't believe that a writer can effectively 100% distance himself from the characters that he creates. Especially, when it's a first-person narration - you really have to think like your character. For example, I would never be able to write a confession of a rapist if I didn't even for a little tiny bit felt like enjoyed the fantasy of it.

And to me the fact that a lot of people genuinely enjoy this novel, says that although the society condemns such behavior it is not alien to human nature.

One excuse is that it a great piece of literature. I will admit that it's well written but would you praise Mein Kampf if the style was superb? I think not.

Another excuse is that the novel made me think. Well, it did but so would any book that talks about an extreme world view with such admiration (especially when the book is so popular).
 
Interestingly, Nabokov was all about style to the point where he could fill several pages without saying anything in particular and it would be a masterpiece in the eyes of his admirers. And even though I admit he knew how to handle words, phrases, sentences, paragraphs, he really could not tell a story. And the only time he managed to come up with an intriguing plot, he created this. Maybe he should have stuck with decorative writing.

Having said all that, I am not at all trying to say that this book should be banned. I think that people should be honest and tell it as it is. This is not a love story (Lolita clearly doesn't want to have sex with Humbert Humbert and suffers from their relationship, he even admits that she cries every night) so if you think it is a love story, admit that you like the idea of raping 12 year-old girls.